Today we have an excellent guest post from Trish Nicholson, who gives some good advice on using real life experiences in our writing.
We are all familiar with the advice:
‘write about what you know’ but what does it mean?
When Susan, a new member of our writing
group, responded to feedback on her story, wailing, “But it’s true. It happened
like that!” we all realised how ambiguous that statement is. Yet it is
basically good advice for writing both fiction and non-fiction, so I thought
about it, and this is what I came up with.
‘Real life’ is not a story:
Our lives are made up of disconnected actions:
catching the train to work, texting friends, changing a nappy, pushing a vacuum
cleaner around; and of discontinuous shreds of conversation full of ums and
errs. The actions don’t make a story, and the ums and errs don’t make dialogue,
until writing craft is applied to organise them into plots and scripts. Writing
craft is based on reality, but makes
sense of it by selecting only those elements that can be woven into a sequence
with a specific meaning and purpose. Even fantasy has to be grounded in some
idea of reality for readers to comprehend it. A story is an interpretation of life
crafted into words, and so is an article or an essay.
And unlike ‘real life’, stories and
articles have a finite ending – happy, tragic or enigmatic, they have to end.
Have you noticed how little closure there is in our lives – even when we seek
it? Work schedules, relationships, other people’s expectations, our own
feelings; there are always frayed threads everywhere because, well, ‘life goes
on.’ One of the important things to learn about writing ‘what you know’ is how
to structure it to a satisfying conclusion.
We know more than we think:
However mundane or boring life seems at
times, our experiences and perceptions are all part of the human saga and a
rich vein of knowledge for a writer. To tap this source, we need to increase
our awareness of what is going on around us, and inside us, and to record it.
Whether in a diary, a prized moleskin notebook, or on the back of the gas bill,
we should note not only what our five senses show us, but what we think it
means and how we feel about it. Recording includes photographs – so easy now
with digital devices – because we can mine these later, for visual clues and
stimulation. We can then expand our personal knowledge with research where
necessary.
When writing travelogue, I start by
deciphering the scribbles in my journals – a collection of little black
journalists’ tablets because they fit easily into a pocket, so are always at
hand. Amongst all the facts – locations, dates, names – are snippets of
overheard conversation, brief character sketches, stray words that come to mind
to encapsulate what is happening, and cryptic comments about how I feel (often
a great source of amusement to me on re-reading).
While studying my notes, I scroll
through the photographs. Although we joke about tourists who ‘click it now and
see it later’ – better photographs do result from immersion in a scene before
pressing the button – a picture, even
long after the event, can recall not only the occasion, but the smell, touch
and sound associated with it. This process is equally productive for
‘experiencing’ the setting of your novel as you write.
Writing our experience:
The only difference between writing our
experience as fiction, and as non-fiction, is what we write – not how
we write: rhythm, imaginative language, character development and storytelling
– all these elements of writing craft apply to both. In what they write,
fiction writers have greater freedom to use their knowledge to create ‘worlds’
– within the limitations of reader credibility. Non-fiction writers have a duty
to adhere to facts, and to honour the truth to the best of their ability. We
are all subjective, that is an inescapable fact, but being aware of it, and
sharing enough with readers for them to see where our truth comes from, helps
achieve balance.
Within these constraints, non-fiction
writers are free to express their experience and knowledge in the creative form
and style of their choice. I’ll give you an example. My journal entry for a
ruined, sixteenth century, fortified monastery included some dry historical
facts, and the phrase, “massive structure
– mist...eerie silence.”
With the photograph beside me as I wrote
Journey in Bhutan, it became this: Standing in this quiet spot, listening to
birds singing and leaves crinkling in the breeze, it is hard to imagine these hillsides
echoing with the thunderous clatter of war horses and the deadly whisper of
arrows, but since at least the seventh century, various Tibetan war-lords and
rulers have tried to expand their influence into the favoured valleys of
Bhutan.
I was attempting to whisper in the
reader’s ear, to place them where I was standing, by using imagery. For Susan,
trying to turn ‘what she knew’ into a short story, she already had the imagery,
the inner experience; what she needed to do was create more ‘facts’ – incidents
and conflicts – as well as a satisfying ending.
Trish Nicholson is the author of the illustrated e-book travelogue, Journey in Bhutan: Himalayan Trek in the Kingdom of the Thunder Dragon.
~~~~~
Critique Service for Writers
Flash 500 Flash Fiction Competition
Flash 500 Humour Verse Competition
Great post, Trish - and it's interesting to see how someone else tackles the challenge of taming travel journals, reshaping them so but still telling a truthful story.
ReplyDeleteThanks Jo, you will understand that better than most - and I love the word 'taming' - but as I switch each day from short stories to travelogue and essays or articles, I realise even more that though the mind-set is different, the writing craft is not.
ReplyDeleteWhat a wonderful post Trish,you really have inspired me. As you know I write on my blog about things that happen in my life my hubby will sometimes say some things are not strictly true and my reply is well the truth needs to be stretched sometimes to make it interesting to others.
ReplyDeleteSo pleased it was helpful, Anne, and you are absolutely right: if you are writing fiction,a story needs to be created, even though you use real life experiences woven into it, or as the initial inspiration. On the other hand, a formal memoir is expected to be truthful - but it can only be the truth as the writer sees it. Happy writing.
ReplyDeleteThis is so useful. We have our Writers Abroad 'Foreign Encounters' anthology coming up, and I shall certainly take your inspiration into account when preparing my submission. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteThank you Paola, delighted it was useful. Good luck with your submission.
ReplyDeleteThanks,a wonderful guide and a great source of encouragement.
ReplyDelete